Myths, Mistakes, and Musings: Ed’s Reflections on SEO

Hey folks, it’s Edd here again. I’ve been thinking a lot lately about some of the odd and interesting aspects of SEO that we all come across. You know, those little quirks and myths that seem to persist no matter how much we try to debunk them. So I thought I’d share some thoughts on a few topics that have been on my mind, inspired by some questions I’ve been mulling over for future podcast guests.

What’s the Most Ridiculous SEO Myth That Needs to Disappear?

Honestly, there are plenty of myths floating around in the SEO world, but the one that really gets my goat is the idea that all you need is links. Don’t get me wrong, backlinks are important. They’re like the currency of credibility online. But the notion that you can skimp on quality content and just ride the wave of backlinks to the top of the rankings is just plain daft.

I’ve seen it time and time again—people obsessing over accumulating as many links as possible, often without considering the relevance or quality of those links. It’s like trying to build a house by stacking bricks haphazardly without any mortar. Sure, you might get some structure, but it’s not going to hold up.

Great content is the foundation of any successful SEO strategy. You can have a ton of links pointing to your site, but if the content isn’t up to scratch, visitors will bounce faster than you can say “Google algorithm”. Conversely, quality content can start to rank on its own merits and naturally attract backlinks over time. Content first, links second—that’s the mantra we should be embracing.

The Weirdest Thing I’ve Done for Backlinks

Now, I haven’t delved into anything too outlandish in the quest for backlinks. I’m not one for grand gestures or wild stunts. But there was that one time we decided to sponsor Brighton SEO and thought we’d do something a bit different. Instead of the usual flyers or brochures stuffed into delegate bags, we went with scratch cards.

Yep, actual scratch cards with prizes and everything. Every delegate got one, and everyone was guaranteed to win something—even if it was just a two-week free trial of Keywords People Use. We had bigger prizes too, like year-long subscriptions, tickets to future events, and even hoodies.

It was a bit of a punt, to be honest. Cost a fair bit and we weren’t entirely sure how it would go down. But the idea was to generate a bit of buzz, get people talking about us, and hopefully pick up some backlinks along the way. It was certainly out of my comfort zone, but sometimes you’ve got to try something different to stand out.

Speaking of weird and wonderful tactics, if you haven’t heard of Mark Rofe, you should check him out. He’s the bloke who flew from Barcelona to the UK just to get a Nando’s at Gatwick Airport, then flew straight back. Got himself in the papers and loads of backlinks in the process. He’s even put up billboards advertising himself for dating. Now that’s dedication to the cause!

Keyword Research Tools vs Analytics Tools: Which Would I Give Up?

This is a tough one, but if I had to choose, I’d give up keyword research tools over analytics tools. I know, shocking coming from someone who runs a keyword research platform. But hear me out.

For years, I operated without keyword research tools and still managed to build successful sites with heaps of traffic. The thing is, without analytics, you’re flying blind. You need to know what’s happening on your site—where the traffic is coming from, which pages are performing, what’s resonating with your audience.

Analytics give you real, tangible data about your site’s performance. Keyword research tools are helpful, no doubt, but they’re based on estimates and forecasts. They can guide you, but analytics show you the actual results of your efforts.

Understanding your audience’s behaviour through analytics allows you to refine your content strategy, optimise user experience, and ultimately drive better results. So, while I’d miss the insights from keyword research tools, I reckon I could get by without them as long as I have solid analytics to lean on.

Time Travel: Fix a Past SEO Mistake or Peek at Future Algorithms?

If given the chance, I’d definitely hop in a time machine and go back to fix a past mistake. Specifically, I’d go back to the days before Google’s Penguin update. Back then, like many others, we were indulging in some dodgy link-building practices—buying links, engaging in a bit of spammy behaviour. It was the Wild West of SEO, and we were all trying to game the system a bit.

When Penguin rolled out, it hit us hard. Traffic plummeted, and it took us a good couple of years to recover fully. Looking back, we realised that if we’d focused on creating quality content and building legitimate links from the start, we’d have been in a much stronger position.

Going back and fixing that mistake would have saved us a lot of headaches and probably made us a fair bit more successful in the long run. As for peeking at future algorithms, well, even if you knew what was coming, there’s no guarantee you’d know how to prepare for it. Google’s always evolving, and sometimes it’s better to focus on solid, time-tested strategies rather than chasing the next big thing.

—

So there you have it—some reflections on myths, mistakes, and the lengths we’ll go for a good backlink. SEO is ever-changing, but some principles remain constant. Focus on quality content, understand your audience through analytics, and maybe think twice before buying that sketchy backlink package.

If you’ve got any thoughts or want to share your own SEO anecdotes, feel free to drop a comment. Always interested to hear what others are experiencing out there in the wild world of SEO.